Throttle Buff is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Read our affiliate disclosure.
How we chose: this guide is research-based, built from manufacturer specifications, safety certifications and owner feedback rather than hands-on testing. How we research.
The best Stage 1 air cleaner for most Milwaukee-Eight Harleys is the Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker: it has a billet backing plate with an integrated breather, a reusable pre-oiled filter and one of the biggest owner followings of any Harley intake. If you ride in California or want to stay emissions-friendly, the CARB-approved S&S Stealth is the pick. For billet looks, the Vance & Hines VO2 X stands out, and Twin Cam and Sportster owners have proven kits too. Here are six options, how to choose and why you need a tune.
Quick picks
-
Best overall (Milwaukee-Eight)
Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker
- Fits (as listed)
- Harley 2017–2026 (check model)
- Breather
- Integrated
- Price tier
- $$
-
-
-
Best retro style
- Fits (as listed)
- Milwaukee-Eight 2017–2025
- Breather
- Integrated
- Price tier
- $$
- Best for Twin Cam: Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker (Twin Cam)
- Best for Sportster: Vance & Hines VO2 Cage Fighter
Harley Stage 1 air cleaners compared
| Air cleaner | Fits (as listed) | Breather | Filter | Emissions note | Price tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arlen Ness Big Sucker (M8) | Harley 2017–2026 (check model) | Integrated | Pre-oiled, reusable | Check listing | $$ |
| S&S Stealth | Milwaukee-Eight 2017–2025 | Check listing | Included | CARB approved (stock fuel system) | $$ |
| V&H VO2 X | Touring / Softail 2023–2026 | Check listing | K&N Xstream, washable | Check listing | $$$ |
| K&N Street Metal Shaker | Milwaukee-Eight 2017–2025 | Integrated | Oversized K&N high-flow | Check listing | $$ |
| Arlen Ness Big Sucker (Twin Cam) | Twin Cam 1999–2017 | Hidden, O-ringed | Water-resistant synthetic, reusable | Check listing | $$ |
| V&H VO2 Cage Fighter | Sportster 1991–2022 | Check listing | Washable, reusable | Check listing | $$ |

Fitment ranges are from RevZilla’s listings. Price tiers are relative within this list, and prices change.
What a Stage 1 air cleaner does
The stock Harley air cleaner is designed to be quiet and meet emissions rules, not to flow the most air. A Stage 1 air cleaner uses a larger, less restrictive filter and a smoother inlet so the engine can breathe more easily. Combined with a freer-flowing exhaust and a matching tune, it’s the classic “Stage 1” upgrade. On its own, it can make the engine run leaner, which is why a tune matters; see our guide to the best fuel management systems for Harley-Davidson.
The 6 best Stage 1 air cleaners for Harley-Davidson
1. Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker: best overall for Milwaukee-Eight

The Big Sucker is one of the most popular Harley intakes, with over 500 owner reviews on RevZilla across its versions. Arlen Ness claims horsepower increases of up to 21%. The Milwaukee-Eight kit has a billet aluminum backing plate with an integrated crankcase breather for a clean look without external hoses, a radius air inlet for unobstructed airflow and a black pre-oiled high-performance filter that you can clean and reuse. There are separate versions for 2023-and-newer Touring and Softail models, so check fitment carefully.
Who it’s for: Milwaukee-Eight owners who want the most proven Stage 1 intake.
2. S&S Cycle Stealth: best CARB-approved option

The S&S Stealth has a subtle look and a high-strength synthetic polymer backing plate designed to reduce heat transfer to the intake air. Cooler air is denser, which helps cylinder filling. It’s CARB approved for stock fuel system applications, which makes it a rare street-legal choice for California riders. The kit includes the backing plate, filter and hardware, plus an actuator cover that hides the throttle-by-wire servo motor. It’s made in the USA, and S&S offers Teardrop and Mini Teardrop styles too.
Who it’s for: California riders and anyone who wants an emissions-friendly upgrade.
3. Vance & Hines VO2 X: best billet look

The VO2 X is crowned with a bold CNC-machined billet cover held down with ARP hardware, over a K&N Xstream high-flow filter that’s washable and reusable. It uses Vance & Hines’ large-inlet backing plate and Force Velocity Stack. This version fits 2023–2026 Touring and Softail models. RevZilla lists it at $549.95, so it’s the premium choice here.
Who it’s for: owners of newer Touring and Softail bikes who want a showpiece intake.
4. K&N Street Metal Shaker: best retro style

K&N’s Street Metal Shaker has a cast-aluminum high-volume housing with exaggerated sanded fins for a nostalgic look. Inside is an oversized K&N high-flow filter for long service intervals, a built-in dyno-tuned velocity stack that directs air to the throttle body and an integrated breather system.
Who it’s for: riders who want old-school style on a Milwaukee-Eight.
5. Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker (Twin Cam): best for Twin Cam

For 1999–2017 Twin Cam bikes, the Big Sucker uses a one-piece aluminum backing plate with hidden breathers that are O-ringed at the heads and exit at the mouth of the injector or carb, eliminating external hoses. The radius inlet gives unobstructed airflow, and the water-resistant synthetic filter is easy to clean and reuse.
Who it’s for: Twin Cam owners building a Stage 1 bike. Planning more power? See our guide to the best cam for a 96ci Harley.
6. Vance & Hines VO2 Cage Fighter: best for Sportster

The VO2 Cage Fighter has a minimal, custom look designed to maximize airflow to the filter. It includes a high-flow washable and reusable filter, a large-inlet backing plate and a Force Velocity Stack. RevZilla lists it at $329.95 for Sportsters.
Who it’s for: Sportster riders who want a clean, aggressive intake.
How to choose a Stage 1 air cleaner
Match your engine and year
Milwaukee-Eight, Twin Cam and Sportster engines need different kits, and Harley changed some Touring and Softail parts for 2023. Always check fitment.
Look at the breather design
Hidden or integrated breathers route crankcase vapors without external hoses, which looks cleaner and helps keep oil off the filter.
Think about legality
If you ride in California, look for CARB approval, like the S&S Stealth’s. Elsewhere in the US, the EPA enforces anti-tampering rules, so check each product’s legal status. See CARB for California rules.
Plan the whole Stage 1
The intake works best with a matching pipe and tune. See the best performance exhausts for Harley-Davidson and our Fuelpak guide. Riding something other than a Harley? Our high-quality motorcycle exhaust picks cover sport, ADV and dual-sport bikes.
Installation and care tips
- Most kits bolt on with hand tools; follow the instructions for breather routing. Our tips on working on a motorcycle can help.
- Clean and re-oil reusable filters as the maker recommends.
- After installing, get the bike tuned and keep up with oil changes using one of the best oils for Harley-Davidson.
FAQ
Do I need a tune with a Stage 1 air cleaner?
It’s strongly recommended, because more airflow without more fuel can make the engine run lean.
How much power does a Stage 1 air cleaner add?
It depends on the bike and the rest of the build. Arlen Ness claims up to 21% for the Big Sucker, but most of the gain comes when you combine the intake, exhaust and tune.
Are Stage 1 air cleaners street legal?
Some, like the S&S Stealth, are CARB approved for stock fuel systems. Check each product’s legal status where you live.
Related reading: big bore kits for the Twin Cam 88.
Verdict
For most Milwaukee-Eight Harleys, the Arlen Ness Smooth Stage 1 Big Sucker is the best Stage 1 air cleaner. Choose the CARB-approved S&S Stealth for California, the Vance & Hines VO2 X for billet style, the Big Sucker Twin Cam kit for older bikes and the VO2 Cage Fighter for Sportsters. Whatever you pick, pair it with a tune.
Browse all our accessory guides.

